AirPods 5 Review Roundup: Apple Improves Open-Fit Noise Cancellation

Bottom line: Apple's AirPods 5 start at $129. Per Tom's Guide, the active noise cancellation (ANC) blocks about 50% more noise than the AirPods 4.

Water resistance also improves over the AirPods 4's IP54 rating, according to reviewers. The ANC appears to be limited to the higher-priced model, not the $129 base model.

The open-fit design still means fit decides everything, so try the shape before you commit.

I'm an infrastructure engineer, and I distrust any device that promises "it just works." I've spent years taking pages at 3 a.m., and I know how much open earbuds leak.

So when I read that the AirPods 5 address the biggest complaint people had about the AirPods 4, I went looking for what the published reviews actually say.

Article illustration

I'll be upfront about the limits here. Fit is personal, and your ears are not a reviewer's ears. Read this as one engineer's take on the published reviews, not a lab report.

The One Thing I Hated

The AirPods 4 had a problem I couldn't get past: noise cancellation on a design that doesn't seal your ear canal.

It was a clever trick, but on a train or in an open-plan office, you could tell where the software ended and physics began.

That's the tradeoff of open-fit earbuds. They don't burrow into your ear, so they're comfortable for hours, but they can't lean on a physical seal. ANC gets much easier with silicone tips.

The AirPods 5 look like the first open-fit pair to meaningfully narrow that gap. Tom's Guide and CNN Underscored both describe the AirPods 5 as a clear step up.

Tom's Guide says the ANC blocks 50 percent more noise than the AirPods 4.

What Reviewers Noticed

The test I'd run on anything with a microphone and a battery is simple: wear it through the worst 20 minutes of the week, meaning a loud commute plus a video call with a colleague who talks with a fan running.

Here's what the reviews suggest you'll notice.

None of this is magic. It's a meaningful improvement on a design constraint, and I'd rather have an honest 50% than a marketing claim of "total silence."

Fit Makes or Breaks It

Here's the part reviews keep returning to. SoundGuys put it bluntly: the fit makes or breaks the entire experience.

Because the earbuds don't seal your ear canal, how they sit in your ear decides your noise cancellation, your sound, and how long you can comfortably wear them.

That's a strange thing to say about a $129 product, but it's true. Two people can buy the same pair and have opposite experiences.

One gets a snug, quiet fit, and the other gets earbuds that slowly work loose during a walk.

I'd treat this like a hardware compatibility check:

1. Try before you buy. If you can borrow a pair or test in a store, spend ten minutes shaking your head and walking around.

2. Test with your worst environment. A quiet demo room tells you nothing about a subway.

3. Check the return window. If the fit is wrong, you'll know within a day or two.

The Boring Upgrades That Matter

The flashy spec is the ANC. The one I'd care about as someone who sweats through workouts is durability.

The AirPods 5 have improved water resistance over the AirPods 4's IP54 rating, which should hold up better against sweat and splashes during a workout.

There are two versions. The base model starts at $129 and, as with the AirPods 4 lineup, likely leaves out active noise cancellation.

A higher-priced one adds ANC, a wireless charging case, audible Find My, swipeable volume controls and longer battery life.

Check the exact specs before you buy, because if the AirPods 5 follow the AirPods 4 split, ANC is exclusive to the higher-priced model, so that's where you pay for noise cancellation and the case conveniences.

If noise cancellation is why you're looking at these, the ANC model is the one to consider. If you only want the better fit, sound and water resistance, the base model may be enough.

The case features are nice, but they don't change how the earbuds sound.

The Reality Check

I want to keep myself honest, because "Apple fixed it" is a lazy headline. Three caveats apply.

First, open-fit still has a ceiling. If you fly often or work next to a server room, a sealed pair like the AirPods Pro will beat these. Physics wins.

Second, "50% more noise blocked" is a relative number. It tells you the AirPods 5 improve on the AirPods 4. It doesn't tell you whether they're quiet enough for your particular commute.

It also comes from a single review.

Third, this piece rests on published reviews. I haven't run long-term tests of my own here, and fit varies from person to person.

If a reviewer with a differently shaped ear says the fit failed, I believe them.

What I'd Actually Do

If you're deciding whether to buy, here's my rule of thumb.

If you own the AirPods 4

Don't rush. The improvement looks real, but it's an incremental one. Upgrade if noise cancellation was your main complaint, and skip it if you were happy.

If you're on older AirPods or cheap earbuds

This is an easy yes to consider.

At $129 for the base model, with improved water resistance, it's hard to find a better value in the open-fit category, and the ANC model is the upgrade to look at if noise matters to you.

CNN Underscored calls it one of Apple's best values ever.

Article illustration

If you take calls all day

Test the microphones in the environment where you work. I'd want you to confirm on your own setup before trusting anyone's ears, mine included.

If you're an engineer who wants a "quiet" tool

Think of these like any piece of infrastructure. They're a good default, not a universal one. Pick them for comfort and value, and pick something sealed if you need isolation.

My Verdict

The AirPods 5 don't fix everything. According to the reviews, they improve the thing that mattered most to me, which was making an open-fit design tolerable in noisy places.

That's a real engineering win, and I don't say that lightly.

If noise cancellation is your priority, I'd buy the ANC model, test the fit in the first week, and return them if they don't sit right.

If you only need a comfortable, water-resistant everyday pair, the $129 base model is the cheaper way in.

Either way, it's the same strategy I'd use for any hardware I can't fully evaluate on a spec sheet.

What's the one thing about your earbuds that you've learned to live with, even though you know it's holding you back? I'd like to know whether open-fit or sealed wins for your daily setup.

Sources:

Story Sources

YouTubeyoutube.com